Narrated by William
Gaminara
ISBN: 978-1433261404
Listened to: June 2011 (at age 33)
First time read
What to Expect:
This is the thirteenth book of lots. It actually wouldn’t be too bad of a place to
start – it doesn’t rely on too much of the previous material.
From the Amazon summary:
It
was a hard winter. For Richard Sharpe it was the worst he could remember. He had lost his command to a wealthy man -- a
man with money to buy the promotion Sharpe coveted. And from England came his oldest enemy --
the ruthless, indestructible Hakeswill -- utterly intent on ruining Sharpe. But Sharpe is determined to change his luck. And the surest way is to lead the bloody
attack on the impregnable fortress town of Badajoz , a road to almost certain death -- or
unimagined glory.
My Reactions
(spoilers!):
Overall:
I keep thinking that I need a break from
this series so that I’ll have a reaction other than “ditto”. But then I head out on a road trip for work,
and I pop in the next book in the series.
They’re good. Not unique, or
particularly challenging at this point, but still interesting.
In the latest Sharpe novel, we get to see a
bit of siege warfare, and the return of Sgt. Hakeswill. Sharpe’s romantic life gets a bit of
movement, and, other than another battle going by, we end up pretty much where
we started.
I felt that the book was repetitive in too
many places – both in the descriptions, the actions, and the phrasing. It was perhaps worse in the audiobook
format, since I couldn’t just gloss over the repeated bits. In most places, the repetition seemed to be a
conscious stylistic choice, but I don’t agree with that choice.
Otherwise, it was a satisfying listen, and
I’m not sure that I’ve ever come across a villain as completely loathsome as
Sgt. Obadiah Hakeswill. He certainly
livens up an otherwise unremarkable story.
As ever, I greatly enjoy listening to
William Gaminara’s voicing of the Sharpe novels.
Rating: 3
Other Opinions:
Pretty slim pickings in the review department
– pretty much all I could find were reviews of the BBC
miniseries. If you know of a decent
review, please let me know in the comments.
No comments:
Post a Comment