Tor, Copyright 2006, 415 pages
ISBN: 978-0-7653-4474-8
Read: July 2012 (at age 35)
First time read
What to Expect:
This is book #6 of the Symphony of
Ages. I got fooled by the cover blurb
into thinking it was #4. It is
definitely the initial part of a story.
From the back cover:
Two
gatherings of great import are taking place:
The first is a convocation of dragons, who gather in a primeval forest
glade – the site of the horrific ending of Llauron, one of the last of their
kind. They mourn not only his
irrevocable death, but also the loss of the lore and control over the earth
that it represents.
The
second gathering is a council of war:
Ashe and Rhapsody, rulers of the alliance that protects the Middle
Continent; Gwydion, the new Duke of Navarne; Anborn, the Lord Marshal; Achmed,
the King of Ylorc, and Grunthor, his Seargeant-Major. Each brings news that forms the pieces of a
great puzzle.
As
each piece is added, it becomes quite clear: War is coming, the likes of which
the world has never known.
My comments: (spoilers ahoy!)
Overall:
This isn’t really a fair review. I read the
book out of order, and that really, really should not be done in a series like this.
Now that that’s out of the way, here are my
reactions.
I really didn’t like this book much at
all. I was looking forward to reading
it, as I quite enjoyed the original trilogy, other than the sappy unnecessary
wedding at the end. This one – I didn’t
actually feel like I’d missed much despite having skipped two books. That’s a bad sign to start with. The only thing was that I wasn’t invested in
the characters, and it took most of the book to even figure out where the story
was, and what was just background.
There was a LOT of exposition. In the first half of the book, it varied
between direct narration infodumps, “as you know, Bob”-styled unrealistic
conversations, and conferences where everyone infodumps, in character. The second half-or-so of the book at least
added a few action scenes between the infodumps.
So that’s the plot. The characters were all right, I guess, but
the randomly occurring occasional dropping into pseudo-medieval language by
some of the characters bothered me. It
just didn’t help. It wasn’t even like
specific characters had that as a speech characteristic, it was just
random. By this time in the series, we
have some serious power creep going on – the magic gear was too powerful, and
the characters were godlike, and it got in the way. The exposition kept saying that the enemy was
terribly powerful and evil and all that, but we didn’t really ever get shown
it. All we saw were Kill Bill-esque 1
vs. 50 swordfights, in which the 50 were terribly, terribly outnumbered.
Anyway. That’s probably enough
ranting. I nearly didn’t finish the book. I probably shouldn’t have. At the end of it, I have no desire to read
books 4 and 5, and also no desire to pick up whatever books are left in the
series.
Rating: 2
Other opinions:
Didn't like it much, despite liking the rest of the series.
Loved it.
No comments:
Post a Comment